
Ride the BWO Hatch: Tying the Deadly Comparadun for Fly Fishing Success
The anticipation hangs thick in the air. The water's surface, once still, begins to dimple with subtle rises. It's a moment every fly fisher lives for: the start of a Blue Wing Olive (BWO) hatch. These prolific mayflies, with their delicate wings and tantalizing dance on the water, can turn a slow day into an unforgettable angling experience. But are you truly prepared to capitalize on this insect phenomenon? The key to unlocking BWO magic lies in your fly box, and no BWO arsenal is complete without the deadly Comparadun.
The Allure of the BWO Hatch
Blue Wing Olives are a staple food source for trout in rivers and streams across the globe. Their hatches, often occurring in cooler weather conditions, can be incredibly prolific, bringing even the wariest trout to the surface. Missing out on a BWO hatch is like missing the main course at a feast. Having the right imitation, presented correctly, is paramount to success. That's where the Comparadun comes in.
The Comparadun: A Fly Fishing Legacy
The Comparadun, a classic dry fly pattern, was originated by Al Caucci and Bob Nastasi in the 1970s. These innovative fly fishers sought to create a more realistic and effective imitation of emerging mayflies. The Comparadun's low-riding profile, designed to mimic the vulnerable posture of a mayfly struggling to break free from its nymphal shuck, proved to be a game-changer. Its effectiveness quickly cemented its place as a go-to pattern for discerning anglers.
Why the BWO Comparadun Reigns Supreme
Among the myriad of BWO imitations, the Comparadun stands out for its realism and consistent performance. Its slender profile, subtle wing, and delicate tail create a convincing illusion that fools even the most selective trout.
That's why the Guides BWO Comparadun is one of the top producing BWO dry fly patterns. You should have them as part of your BWO box, and what sizes you need to carry. The Guides BWO Comparadun uses tailing fibbets for the tail, tapered thread body with a colored mono ribbing to create a slim body with natural segmentation, and use of poly yarn for the wing create an cheaper option that is faster to tie, durable, and effective making it the perfect guide pattern.
Here's why you need a selection of BWO Comparaduns in your fly box:
- Realistic Profile: The Comparadun's low-riding design accurately imitates the vulnerable posture of an emerging mayfly, making it irresistible to trout.
- Subtle Presentation: The sparse wing and delicate tail create minimal disturbance on the water's surface, preventing spooking wary fish.
- Versatility: The Comparadun can be adapted to imitate various mayfly species by adjusting the size, color, and materials.
- Essential Sizes: Carry a range of sizes, typically from #16 to #22, to match the specific size of BWOs hatching in your local waters.
Guides BWO Comparadun Fly Tying Tutorial
Ready to tie your own deadly BWO Comparaduns? Watch our comprehensive step-by-step video tutorial and learn how to create this guide-approved pattern:
Guides BWO Comparadun Materials List
Here's a complete list of materials you'll need to tie the Guides BWO Comparadun:
- Hook: Moonlit Premium TOGATTA ML102 sz14-20
- Thread/Body: Semperfli Classic Waxed 12/0 Olive Dun
- Tail: Semperfli Tail Fibre Fibbets Medium Olive
- Rib: Semperfli Mono Ribbing 0.1mm Olive
- Wing: Semperfli Predator Fiber Silver Baitfish
- Thorax: Moonlit Fly Fishing Deaver Dry Fly Dubbing Olive
Simplify Your Tying with Our BWO Comparadun Kit
Don't want the hassle of gathering all the materials individually? We've got you covered! Grab our Guides BWO Comparadun Dry Fly Tying Kit. Simply pick the size you want to tie, and everything else is automatically added to your cart for you. It's the easiest way to stock up on everything you need to tie this essential pattern.
BWO Hatch Chart: Be Ready When the Hatch Hits
Knowing when and where to expect BWO hatches is crucial for fly fishing success. Here's a general hatch chart for different regions:
Region |
Best Weather Conditions |
Time of Day |
Peak Hatch Season |
US (West) |
Overcast, cool |
Mid-morning/Afternoon |
Spring/Fall |
US (East) |
Overcast, cool |
Mid-morning/Afternoon |
Spring/Fall |
Canada |
Overcast, cool |
Mid-morning/Afternoon |
Spring/Fall |
UK |
Overcast, cool |
Mid-morning/Afternoon |
Spring/Summer/Autumn |
Europe |
Overcast, cool |
Mid-morning/Afternoon |
Spring/Summer/Autumn |
Important Note: These are general guidelines. Local conditions and specific river systems can influence hatch timing. Always observe the water and insect activity to determine the best time to fish.
Stay Tuned for More Fly Fishing Tips!
Don't forget to subscribe to our YouTube Channel for more great fly tying tutorials, fishing tips, and gear reviews. We're constantly adding new content to help you become a more successful angler!
Conclusion: Tie, Fish, and Conquer the BWO Hatch
The BWO hatch is a fly fisher's dream, a chance to connect with nature and experience the thrill of fooling a wild trout. By adding the Guides BWO Comparadun to your fly box and understanding the nuances of BWO hatches, you'll be well-equipped to ride the wave of success. So, tie some flies, hit the water, and get ready for some unforgettable fly fishing adventures!
Leave a comment